I have finally found a pencil eyeliner that I am in love with. I never had great luck with pencil eyeliners until now. They were either too hard to apply and/or not very pigmented. I'm talking about the Milani Liquif'eye Metallic Eye Liner pencils. They are creamy, easy to apply, stay on quite well (even in the waterline) and they are easy on the pocket book!
I tried the black one first to see what I thought and once I confirmed how awesome they are, I went back to get the other colors. They come in black, brown, aqua, silver and gold. I found them at Walgreen's for $6.49. The brown is a new color and I believe the gold is too. I hope Milani will continue carrying them and add more colors. I would love to see a purple and gunmetal color!
Below are swatches of the colors and I can tell you these swatches do not do the colors enough justice. The Aqua is to die for gorgeous!!
I did a brown smoky eye the other day and used a brown cream eyeliner on my lower lash line and then put the Milani gold under that. It looked amazing!!